Skip to main content

Civil Debate


Do the benefits of genetically modified foods (GMOs) for human consumption outweigh the harms for the health of people and the environment?

Should the government impose an age limit of 18 on the use of social media platforms as it imposes age limits on the use of tobacco and alcohol? 

Should physician-assisted suicide be legalized in the United States as a compassionate option for terminally ill patients?

With passionate defenders on both sides, our eighth grade boys recently faced off in a series of debates on these and other hot-button, complex public health issues.

The boys were assigned to find and read an article that discussed a current issue in public health in which two or more “sides” were presented. They then selected the topics that they wanted to debate. In their opening statements, arguments, rebuttals, crossfire questions, and closing summaries the debaters were judged on how well they made distinct arguments supported by evidence, explained the science, and presented in a captivating and persuasive style.

Our science program's debate challenge calls upon boys to research and critically analyze complicated ideas and issues, and to employ debating skills they have learned and practiced. They must present persuasively, using evidence and confident public speaking ability, as they marry copious preparation with quick thinking and the ability to respond and persuade "in the moment." 

They might argue a position they personally hold, or be tasked with advocating for an opposing viewpoint. One eighth grader noted that having to argue a position he did not agree with made for a good exercise: "I had to argue the con on the issue of physician assisted suicide, but I really was pro. This helped my debating skills. When you argue a con, you need to force the debater on the pro side to counter your counter." 

Another eighth grader reflected: "The most challenging aspect was learning to think and respond on the fly. I prepared by anticipating points I thought the other side would make ... Overall, I think it is most important to be able to debate respectfully about an issue, even if you strongly disagree with another person's opinion." 

That's exactly what we seek to achieve through this debate series: a challenging academic experience that encourages our boys to embrace the value of civil discourse. 


Popular posts from this blog

"The Wisdom Within" - Building Student Motivation Through Choice

In the third entry of our Teaching Boys Initiative quarterly blog series, Master Teacher Jim Barbieri explores how providing boys with agency to choose builds motivation and enhances learning. BUILDING STUDENT MOTIVATION THROUGH CHOICE By the time I was eight years old, I had become completely absorbed in all things baseball. Living in New York was perfect for a baseball fan; although I was a Mets fan thanks to my idol, Tom Seaver, I was also interested in learning about all the amazing Yankees stars of yore. How could I call myself a baseball fan if I didn’t know the history and records of stars like Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, and Yogi Berra? I loved collecting baseball cards and reading the career statistics of each player on the back. Looking through my collection one day, I discovered that I shared a birthday with the legendary Pittsburgh Pirates outfielder Roberto Clemente. At eight years old, I was crushed to hear the news that he had died tragically in a plane crash while trying to ...
Read more

"The Wisdom Within" - The Superpower of Performance

In the following entry of our Teaching Boys Initiative blog series, Saint David's Director of Music and Master Teacher Jeffrey Moore explores how participating in performances and productions build transformative competencies, transmit values, and inspire boys to excel. Jose Antonio Abreu, one of the leading educators in classical music and the founder of El Sistema said this: “Music has to be recognized as an agent of social development in the highest sense, because it transmits the highest values  — solidarity, harmony, mutual compassion. And it can unite an entire community and express sublime feelings.”¹ At Saint David’s School, performance begins in the very first years. Each class, from Pre-K through Eighth Grade, presents their work to an audience of peers and parents, whether it is a story, a skit, a play, a lecture, or a musical presentation. But the increasing complexity and demands on our boys to push themselves to another level is the key to their development and succes...
Read more

"The Wisdom Within" - Writing and Thinking

In our continuing efforts through the Teaching Boys Initiative at Saint David's School ™ , one of our visiting scholars, Dr. Ric Campbell, engages in ongoing reflective practice with our faculty. Below, Dr. Campbell shares an example of a freewriting initiative that was born from the collaboration between literature teacher Jamie MacNeille and history teacher Drew Burton, who sought to address forms of student engagement in their respective disciplines.  WRITING and THINKING:  A Learning Community Engaged in the Knowledge-Making Practices of the Disciplines “Whoa, this freewriting is really helpful !” The above quote by a sixth-grade literature student captures a revelatory moment; he has discovered the wealth of ideas at the end of his pen as he writes to describe what he is noticing in the novel the class is reading and discovers that what he notices leads to questions, and that those questions, in turn, lead to bigger ideas. “All there is to thinking is seeing something not...
Read more