Skip to main content

Exploring Others' Perspectives in History's Lessons and Questions

School is not about answers, it's about questions—especially “why” questions we ask boys and they ask each other. "Why" targets the heart of any matter, it asks not for a simple response but for careful consideration, exploration, and reasoned analysis. At the core of inquiry is respect for difference; to be able to entertain a different perspective with an open mind. It was Aristotle who once wrote, "It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it." It is with an open mind and intellectual curiosity that our boys can critically analyze ideas and issues.


In a recent publication of Saint David's Magazine, History Curriculum Chair Joe Shapiro addresses this in his piece entitled: "Exploring Others' Perspectives in History's Lessons and Questions." The article demonstrates our widely used Socratic seminar approach -- in this example employed during a sixth grade history unit on the Hamilton/Jefferson debates. During these seminars, half the boys engage in a discussion around a topic, while the teacher and the other half of the class take notes and evaluate the boys on their logic and how well they listen to their classmates' points of view. Through this process, our boys defend their arguments while critically analyzing opposing arguments and cultivating a respect for difference. 

Link to Article: 
Photos are from fall 2020.

 

Popular posts from this blog

William Burke '10 Explores the Mother-Son Relationship in Special Chapel Talk

William Burke '10 returned to Saint David's this morning to speak to our fifth graders and their moms or special friends about the mother-son relationship. Will, a graduate of Regis and Georgetown who works as an Analyst at BlackRock, reminded our boys of the instrumental role their moms play in myriad aspects of their daily lives. Using the experience of boys who play hockey as an example, he observed, "Mom is always there, she's your gear sponsor, your Uber to the games, rooting you on during the game and waiting afterward with donuts and hot chocolate." Win or lose, a son's biggest fan is his mom. As he referenced our school's mission, Will remarked, " Ut viri boni sint  (that they be good men)  are beautiful words, but how do we learn to be a good man?" He noted that the boys can learn from teachers, coaches, and other students, while adding that they receive vital wisdom, support, and guidance from their mothers. "Behind e...
Read more

"The Wisdom Within" - Writing and Thinking

In our continuing efforts through the Teaching Boys Initiative at Saint David's School ™ , one of our visiting scholars, Dr. Ric Campbell, engages in ongoing reflective practice with our faculty. Below, Dr. Campbell shares an example of a freewriting initiative that was born from the collaboration between literature teacher Jamie MacNeille and history teacher Drew Burton, who sought to address forms of student engagement in their respective disciplines.  WRITING and THINKING:  A Learning Community Engaged in the Knowledge-Making Practices of the Disciplines “Whoa, this freewriting is really helpful !” The above quote by a sixth-grade literature student captures a revelatory moment; he has discovered the wealth of ideas at the end of his pen as he writes to describe what he is noticing in the novel the class is reading and discovers that what he notices leads to questions, and that those questions, in turn, lead to bigger ideas. “All there is to thinking is seeing something not...
Read more

"The Wisdom Within" - Learning as Deliberate Practice

In the following  Wisdom Within post, Visiting TBI Scholar Dr. Ric Campbell continues his blog series on our faculty’s reflective practice program. This entry explores how three Saint David's teachers collaborated to build "self regulated" students: "expert learners who take increasing control over their learning while participating as respectful, caring members of their classroom learning community." LEARNING AS DELIBERATE PRACTICE “If schools are going to help all students become expert learners, the metacognitive capabilities of learners must be acknowledged, cultivated, and exploited. Students must be actively engaged in their own learning and knowledge building; they must be able to effectively direct their personal quest for knowledge and skills, to judge for themselves whether they understand, and to know what to do when they need more information.”  [1] Perhaps the two most important outcomes of learning across the rich and varied curriculum at Saint Dav...
Read more